In the weekly portion of Yitro, Moses appoints judges by 10’s, 50’s, 100’s, and 1000’s (see Exodus 18:25). With the exception of the judge by 50, each judge was in charge of a group of 10. Why was there a judge by 50? He doesn’t seem to fit the pattern.

Your question is a very good one, to which there are probably many answers.

The ‘Oznaim laTorah’ (Insights into the Torah) explains that the officers of 1000 and 100 were the judges – the upper and lower courts. The officers of 50 and 10 were the policemen. The judges of 100 were nevertheless capable judges, and therefore could be supervised on a ratio of 1:10 by the higher court system. However the policemen were basically average public (despite being selected for their honest and upright moral character), and therefore called for the higher ratio of 1:5 for supervision.

This is

only one possible reply (as I said). Keep your eyes open everywhere for other answers.

Thank you for the question.

Rabbi David Sedley

Original post by ATR

Chanuka Sukkot Bar Mitzvah Kosher Travel Menorahs Kosher Reform Jews Tallitot Mezuzah Jewish World News Kosher Gifts Orthodox Jews Jewish Social Talitot Chapel Caps Jewish Politics Chanukah Kosher Holidays Chanukkah Jewish Holidays Antisemitism Reform Jew Rabbi Torah Cover jewish Shuls Torah Scrolls Kosher Hotels Shabbat Free Artscroll Yarmulka Menorah Jewish Music Ask the Rabbi Benchers Reform Jewish Personals Orthodox Mezzuzah Synagogue Tallis Rosh Hashanah Ketubot Kosher Students Talmud Jewish Singles Soncino Communities And Synagogues Taleisim